Featured Nonprofits
Nonprofits
How to Make the Case for Marketing Investment to Your Nonprofit Board
You know your nonprofit needs better marketing. You've seen the data showing declining donor engagement. You've watched other organizations grow while yours plateaus. You've done the research and found partners who could help.
Now comes the hard part: convincing your board.
Many board members see marketing as “overhead”, a necessary evil that diverts precious dollars away from programs and people in need. They're not wrong to be cautious with donor funds. But they may be wrong about what marketing actually does for your mission.
Here's how to make the case for nonprofit marketing investment in language your board will understand and respond to.
Reframe the Conversation
The biggest hurdle isn't the budget itself. It's how your board thinks about marketing.
Old framing: “Marketing is an expense that takes money away from programs.”
New framing: “Marketing is an investment that multiplies our capacity to deliver programs.”
The difference matters. Expenses are costs you try to minimize. Investments are strategic decisions you make to grow.
Let's look at the math. If you spend $5,000 on a targeted donor acquisition campaign and it generates $25,000 in new donations, that's not $5,000 less for programs. That's $20,000 MORE for programs than you would have had otherwise.
Your board understands return on investment. They think this way about endowments, fundraising events, and capital campaigns. Help them see that nonprofit marketing ROI works the same way.
When you invest in marketing, you're not spending mission dollars. You're generating them.
Address the Common Objections Head-On
You'll face predictable resistance. Here's how to respond to the most common objections:
“We should spend money on programs, not marketing”
This sounds responsible, but it ignores a fundamental truth: without donors, there are no programs. Marketing doesn't compete with your mission. Marketing funds your mission.
Every dollar you invest in reaching new supporters creates sustainable funding for the work you do. The organizations making the biggest impact aren't choosing between marketing and programs. They're using marketing to expand programs.
“Our donors don't want us spending money on marketing”
This concern comes from the old “overhead myth”, the idea that donors want 100% of their gift going directly to programs. But that myth is dying.
Sophisticated donors understand that sustainable organizations invest in growth. They know that a well-run nonprofit needs infrastructure, including the systems to reach new supporters and communicate impact.
In fact, donors want to give to organizations that are growing and thriving. A nonprofit marketing strategy that brings in new supporters signals health, not waste.
“We tried marketing before and it didn't work”
This objection usually reveals a deeper issue: marketing without strategy doesn't work. Random social media posts, inconsistent email campaigns, and one-off ads won't move the needle.
That's exactly why you need a structured approach. Working with a partner who specializes in nonprofit marketing means you're not guessing. You're following proven strategies that work for organizations like yours.
“We don't have the budget for this”
Start smaller than you think. Google offers a $10,000 per month Ad Grant specifically for nonprofits. That's $120,000 in annual advertising value at zero cost.
You can also propose a pilot program. Test one campaign or work with a partner for 90 days to prove the concept. When you show results, the budget conversation becomes much easier. The real question isn't whether you can afford to invest in marketing. It's whether you can afford not to.
Present Your Proposal Like a Pro
When you're ready to bring this to your board, structure your proposal strategically.
Start with the problem. Use specific numbers: “Donor acquisition has declined 15% over the past two years. If this trend continues, we'll face a $50,000 shortfall next year, which means cutting programs or staff.”
Pro Tip: Make the stakes clear. Your board needs to understand that doing nothing isn't neutral. It's a choice with consequences.
Present the solution. “We've identified a marketing partner who specializes in nonprofit organizations. They've helped similar groups increase donor acquisition by an average of 35% in the first year.”
Pro Tip: Show that you've done your homework. This isn't a whim. It's a researched recommendation.
Show the math. Be conservative with your projections. If your partner estimates you could acquire 100 new donors in six months, present 75. Under-promise and over-deliver.
Pro Tip: Break down the cost per donor acquired and the projected lifetime value of each new donor. Boards respond to concrete numbers.
Propose a pilot. “Let's commit to 90 days and measure results before making a longer-term decision. We'll track new donors acquired, cost per donor, and total revenue generated.”
Pro Tip: A pilot reduces risk and gives skeptical board members a clear exit point if results don't materialize.
Define your metrics. Spell out exactly what success looks like: number of new donors, cost per acquisition, email list growth, website traffic from target audiences, revenue generated from new donor segments.
Pro Tip: When board members know how you'll measure success, they can hold you accountable. That builds trust.
What Happens After You Get Board Approval
Getting the green light is just the beginning. Set clear expectations about what comes next.
Working with a nonprofit marketing partner typically starts with strategy development. You'll clarify your target audiences, refine your messaging, and build campaigns designed to reach the right people.
Be honest about timelines. Most marketing efforts take 90 days to show meaningful results. Some channels, like search engine optimization or content marketing, take even longer. This isn't because marketing is slow. It's because sustainable growth requires building systems, not just running ads.
Plan to report back to your board regularly. Monthly updates on key metrics keep everyone informed and engaged. When board members see progress, they become advocates for continued investment.
Get the Support You Need to Present Your Case
Making the case for nonprofit marketing budget approval doesn't have to feel overwhelming. With the right data and the right partner, you can walk into that board meeting with confidence.
Your mission deserves to reach more people. Your programs deserve sustainable funding. And your board deserves a clear, data-backed proposal that makes the decision easy.
Who we are!
Performance marketing partner for Atlanta medical practices, contractors, and nonprofits. We turn your reputation into revenue.
Sign up to our Newsletters
Looking for something?
Search here…
Recent Blogs
Performance marketing partner for Atlanta medical practices, contractors, and nonprofits. We turn your reputation into revenue.
Who We Serve
What We Do
Get the latest information
All rights reserved.